With the MLB playoffs underway, we decided to proceed with a fun thought exercise involving the managers of clubs in the postseason. We’re aiming to rank the four best managers at this given time. Some might have ‘lesser’ resumes than others left off the list. However, these four stand out above the rest.
4. Stephen Vogt (Cleveland Guardians)
Vogt was a two-time All-Star catcher in the Big Leagues. He enjoyed a decade-long career with six different franchises. From being an elite player to being a backup catcher, he’s seen it all. It’s what has helped him become an excellent manager with the Guardians despite being only 39 years of age. He’s got a tremendous pulse on his team, and since he just recently retired from the game, can relate to the modern player in a way some of these older managers simply can’t do. You can expect a few more AL Central Division titles in the future as long as Vogt is the skipper in Cleveland.
3. Mike Shildt (San Diego Padres)
Shildt is another guy who knows how to manage at a high level. Utilizing a mixture of analytics and old school baseball acumen, he’s got the Padres playing as well as anyone in the sport up to this point. He’s one of the few managers who will let his starters go deep into ballgames without the quick hook. In essence, Shildt has an excellent feel for the position — and it’s a big reason why San Diego is thriving.
2. Dave Roberts (Los Angeles Dodgers)
The resume speaks for itself here. Aside from the World Series title, Roberts has led the Dodgers to seven NL West division titles in eight years. More than that, the expectations surrounding this franchise are unparalleled. There’s immense pressure on the team — and by proxy Roberts — on an annual basis. Roberts is a highly respected guy and is supremely likable within the clubhouse. He’s the type of person who will fight for his players without thinking twice. Being able to manage the egos of multiple superstars on this roster is also a testament to Roberts and his character.
1. AJ Hinch (Detroit Tigers)
Like Vogt and Roberts, Hinch was a former Big Leaguer. Possessing that background is a valuable tool when relating to players. We saw how impressive of a manager he was in Houston when winning a World Series and making two appearances in the famed final round. Now with Detroit, he’s worked his magic with a roster relatively lacking in high-end talent and depth. He’s a master at manipulating the bullpen. Even the lineups he puts out resemble his gritty and competitive disposition. As many have pointed out, preparing to play Detroit with Hinch as the manager is a tough task. He’s unpredictable, creative, and successful.